Witness Attendance in Criminal Courts Proceedings

Prosecution and the Courts Victims and Witnesses Court Operations

Published: 19 Nov 2026

Introduction

Criminal Justice Inspection has published an Inspection of the arrangements for witness attendance in the Crown, Magistrates’ and Youth Courts in Northern Ireland.  The Report examined how criminal justice organisations uphold witness rights, support case progression, reduce avoidable delay and secure outcomes for victims and defendants.


Importance of witness attendance in criminal Courts

People who have witnessed a crime are required to give evidence in Court.  Their absence can cause adjournments and delays, increase costs and adversely affect victims and other witnesses.  It can also make securing a conviction harder, with implications for the wider community.  Witness attendance is, therefore, essential for Courts to hear evidence, reach decisions and deliver justice.

Witness attendance in Northern Ireland’s criminal Courts

In Northern Ireland, the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), the Victim and Witness Care Unit (VWCU) within the Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland (PPS) and the Northern Ireland Courts and Tribunals Service (NICTS) have a shared responsibility to ensure those required attend Court proceedings to give evidence.

Each organisations have a role in securing witness attendance and the Inspection findings showed committed staff and examples of good practice, particularly within the VWCU.  However, communication with witnesses was inconsistent, including late notification of cancellations of Court appearances. 

Witnesses attended Court, but the majority did not give evidence

Inspectors found that most witnesses who attended Court did not give evidence because cases were not ready to proceed.  Case progression was often weak and inconsistent, resulting in adjournments and ineffective hearings.

When cases do not proceed as scheduled, witnesses can experience frustration, anxiety and decreased trust in the criminal justice system.  They may have arranged time off work, made childcare and travel arrangements to attend Court, only to learn at short notice that they are no longer needed.

Speed Up Justice initiatives and Witness Charter

Speeding Up Justice initiatives, such as Remote Evidence Centres and Registered Intermediaries, have helped witnesses give evidence at Court.  However, witnesses were not consistently receiving the services they were entitled to under the Witness Charter.  The Charter sets out standards of care and witness entitlements to information, support and protection, enabling witnesses to participate in criminal proceedings and give evidence to the police or at Court.

Data recording and technology

Late changes of plea by defendants or evidence agreements close to the hearing led to inefficiencies, but limited data collection meant the scale of this inefficiency was not well understood.

Recording of adjournment reasons had improved, but organisations still lacked comprehensive, shared data on witness attendance and witness attrition.  This limited their ability to assess performance, identify avoidable delays and target improvements.

In Northern Ireland, legislation had not kept pace with developments in technology and electronic and digital means of summonsing witnesses and defendants need to be progressed.  As part of this process, it is important to work with witness support services to understand the needs of witnesses and the impact digital summonses can have.

Police Officers and forensic scientists attending Court as witnesses

Large numbers of Police Officers and staff from the Forensic Science Northern Ireland (FSNI) who attended Court did not give evidence. 

This was particularly concerning, as Officers were routinely abstracted from frontline duties and resulted in substantial time and cost.

Inspectors conducted an online survey with PSNI and FSNI Officers. Responses from those who completed the survey indicated they felt the witness attendance process was managed ‘not effectively at all’.

Conclusion

For the past two decades, CJI has identified the non-attendance of victims and witnesses at Court as a major cause of case adjournments.  When cases are delayed, justice takes longer to be delivered, and costs across the system increase. 

Better information sharing and use of modern technology are needed to reduce delays and unnecessary Court attendance.  This Inspection makes four recommendations for improvement that, when implemented, will deliver more structured case progression and timely agreement of witness attendance, creating a more effective and efficient criminal justice system in Northern Ireland in which the community can have confidence.

Graphic Illustration

Stay up to date with CJI’s latest news

Sign up to our newsletter to get regular updates from us delivered directly to your inbox.